Panel Discussions - Wednesday, November 09, 2011
Crowdsourcing and Conflict Prevention
Nick Martin, the President of the organization TechChange captured the essence of how crowdsourcing techniques can strengthen conflict prevention, saying, “In a conflict prevention scenario, good enough information now is probably a lot better than perfect information in two weeks.”
He made the comment during a roundtable discussion on Crowdsourcing and Conflict Prevention co-hosted by IPI and the Bureau for Crisis Prevention and Recovery of the United Nations Development Program (UNDP BCPR) on November 9, 2011.
The meeting was attended by a group of representatives from UN member states, the UN, technology companies, academia, and NGOs. Several presentations and live demonstrations showcased where and how crowdsourcing has been used so far and the special role it plays in crisis mapping in particular.
Crowdsourcing is a methodology involving the use of new technologies and social media for gathering and sharing real-time information generated voluntarily and sometimes anonymously. The aim of the meeting was “to explore further how the use of communication technology can strengthen local and national infrastructures for peace,” said Ozonnia Ojielo of UNDP BCPR. He noted that “the constructive use of newer technology tools provides a crucial opportunity to strengthen broader participation and inclusion in political transformation processes and conflict prevention.”
Mr. Ojielo explained that crowdsourcing was not a replacement for existing frameworks but rather “a complementary tool for early warning,” a tool that provides “a simple and low-cost way of giving opportunity for mobilizing people for localized and participatory preventive multi-stakeholder action in potential conflict situations.”
Crisis mapping is another area where crowdsourcing and user-generated information plays an increasingly large role. During the meeting, Beth Liebert of Google Maps cited several examples, including efforts in the aftermath of the recent earthquake in Japan to map shelters and water supply, where crowdsourcing proved useful and successful: “There’s something about information on a map that people find really useful during a crisis. Something that local and impactful.”
Participants agreed that many challenges remain in applying these technologies for conflict prevention. They range from getting enough people to contribute to and use crowdsourced information, to guarding the personal safety of contributors, and making sure the information is correct.
Maintaining high standards of accuracy involves difficult tradeoffs. Strictly vetting information risks losing the comparative advantage in terms of timeliness provided by crowdsourced information. At the same time, said William Tsuma of the Global Partnership for the Prevention of Armed Conflict (GPPAC), in conflict prevention “the credibility, but also the authenticity of information is just as real as life and death.”
The discussion suggested that the biggest challenge may be ensuring that action is taken based on the information collected via crowdsourcing. Even the best early warning system is only as good as the responses it triggers and to the extent that it enables societies and policy makers to prevent violence from occurring.
Warren Hoge, IPI Senior Adviser for External Relations, moderated the event.
Read transcript
Read meeting summary
Listen to Global Observatory interview with Nick Martin >>
The Global Observatory
Interview with John Prendergast, Co-Founder, Enough Project
Mr. Prendergast discusses the international justice system and the new ground forged by Invisible Children's Kony2012 campaign.
Key Global Events to Watch in May
A list of key upcoming meetings and events with implications for global affairs.
The Global Observatory is a new website by IPI, providing timely analysis on peace and security issues, interviews with leading policymakers, interactive maps, and more.
Recent Events
May 10, 2012
Arbour: What the Rule of Law Means
“In my understanding of the rule of law, fundamentally, what the rule of law means is that it embraces the principle of equality before the law,” Louise Arbour, president of the International Crisis Group (ICG), told an IPI audience on May 10, 2012. Ms. Arbour outlined that this means that no one is above the law and everyone has both equal protection and equal benefit of the law. 
May 03, 2012
Shachtman: Cyber Threats Akin to South Bronx, Not Pearl Harbor
“There’s not a danger of a cyber Pearl Harbor… it’s more like the South Bronx circa 1999, where there’s a danger that it becomes such a tough neighborhood that no one wants to set up shop there and people move out,” Noah Shachtman, editor of the Danger Room blog at Wired magazine and non-resident fellow at the Brookings Institution, told an IPI audience at a panel on cyber security on May 3, 2011.
April 27, 2012
Preventing Conflicts in Africa: The Role of Early Warning and Response Systems
An April 27th roundtable discussion at IPI titled “Preventing Conflicts in Africa: The Role of Early Warning and Response Systems” examined the progress, prospects and challenges of regional and international early warning and response mechanisms to monitor, anticipate, and mitigate potential conflict situations in Africa.